Nottingham’s Five Best Burgers

What can I say – I like Burgers!

I won’t lie – I eat a lot of Burgers. On a walk in Derbyshire the other day, the cows gave me a wide berth and whispered, in cow accent ,

“Doris, that’s her!”

It’s a nice hobby to have. One which takes great skill and dedication, but like I’ve always said: ‘burgers aren’t just for Christmas’ (Now there’s an idea Annie, prime British Beef topped with turkey and eggnog. I’ll let you have that one).

So, it’s with great pride that I can reveal the results of the last 6 months of my burger-testing hobby, here in the foodie city of Nottingham! I’ve done the hard work, you can just sit back with your knife and fork and enjoy the fruitage of my labour.

First off, I’d just like to say that I haven’t listed them in order of preference because, actually, all these burgers are great and it just depends on what I fancy on the day, but rest assured – you won’t be disappointed with any of them.

Nottingham’s Best Burgers…

1. Mud Crab Pacifico – West Bridgford, Nottingham.

My local. A chic establishment in the middle of West Bridgford, a trendy suburb of Nottingham. On Friday’s and Saturdays this joint is usually packed to the rafters and you can’t even hear the music, let alone your conversation, but that’s OK because call in for lunch midweek, order a burger for sustenance and you’ll be able to hear the angels sing. From your stomach.  A smart place with friendly staff (most of the time) and a bright cheery atmosphere.

The Burger…

It’s a double pattie burger, American style if you like, loaded up with cheese and relish and the right amount of saute onions. Labelled on their menu as the ‘2nd Best Cheeseburger’ (so-called because according to Mud Crab themselves, the burger holding the number 1 spot belongs to Ed Debevics in Chicago – how modest of them!) it comes with great fries, and I mean great. What does it for me though is the sauce, whatever they put in that recipe (it’s a secret) it makes for a blinking good mouthful! Plenty of cheese too and a nicely toasted bun, both just compliment the good beef patties and that mouth-watering sauce.

Mud Crab Pacifico Restaurant and Bar in the leafy suburb of West Bridgford, where you'll find one of the best burgers in Nottingham. A fab restaurant with plenty of atmosphere, a great place to take the family.
Let The Stomach Angels Sing!

Mud Crab Pacifico's Burger West Bridgford Nottingham

2. Four Bells Inn – Woodborough, Nottingham

So you’re going to have to hop in the car for this one, but I assure you it’s worth the drive. Situated in a pretty village in North Nottingham, the Four Bells Inn is the kind of establishment that makes everyone feel welcome, no matter who you are. It’s a good pub that does good pub grub. The room’s are cosy, there are some great nooks and crannies and the landlord, Craig, is a down to earth kinda guy. The place won “Best Pub” in the 2015 Nottinghamshire Food and Drink Awards, and I can honestly say everything we’ve eaten here has been top nosh!

The Burger…

A grilled 8oz piece of juicy loveliness, made in their kitchen, from local produce. If I was to ever master the perfect burger at home, this is what I hope it could look like : a rather large chunky English style pattie in a fresh (baked in-house) sesame bun, finished with the modest and simple garnishes of Cheddar, lettuce and tomato. Perfect and in need of nothing else. The meat juices soak into the bread and the herbs and spices give it its own unique Four Bells flavour. The ketchup is there if you want it (Heinz ain’t good enough – a handmade English sauce has been, well, sourced) and the chips are chunky and crispy. Order yourself a bowl of onion rings too – they’re as big as your face but they won’t last long!

A burger and chunky chips from The Four Bells Inn, Woodthorpe, Nottingham one fo the best burger in nottingham on a lunch deal
The Four Bells Burger

Four Bells in Woodborough, Nottingham is a friendly establishment with great food and a great atmosphere. They also do one of the best burgers in Nottingham

3. Annie’s Burger Shack, Nottingham

Well of course Annie’s is on the list – what do you think I am, some kind of minced beef novice!? Here you have your authentic American burger experience being that Annie herself is from across the water, Rhode Island to be exact. She’s owned her shack since 2009 (more recently in the city centre) and actually, it is JUST like some of the diners we ate at in New England on our trip in 2011. She got the brief spot on! Her other love is real ale, which pleases my Mr MLLH no end. The place has a buzz about it and oozes confidence, with a sign above the bar ‘Best Burgers In The Land’ – well it’s on my list isn’t it!?

The Burger…

A serendipitous mix of 85% Beef, 15% Pork, combined with paprika – you’re presented with a pink luscious cylinder caught in a sesame bun. Absolutely cooked to perfection, and that’s the key: it’s not fast food here, excellence requires patience. The garnishes are your standard fare: lettuce, tomato and mayo. But, I guess what brings the crowds are the Burger combinations you can choose from. Title’s like The Big Breakfast (a burger topped with a sausage pattie, bacon, egg and mushroom) or The Caribbean (topped with Jerk Sauce, peppers and a pineapple ring) or The Elvis (topped with peanut butter and jam) or even The Sunday dinner, with its very own yorkshire pudding and roast potatoes in tow. Whatever your tastes, there’s a combination playing your tune. Hardest part is choosing from the 32-strong manifesto – good luck! Or stick with the ‘Bacon Cheddar’ and see for yourself that it lives up to and kicks the ass of many other inferior Nottingham burgers.

One of the best burgers on Nottingham can be found at Annie's Burger Shack in the city centre. The cheeseburger is awesome but there's also a list of over 30 burger combinations to choose from.

The bar at Annie's Burger shack in Nottingham city centre, where they are proud of their selection of ales on offer.

4. Red’s True Barbecue – Nottingham

Red’s boast loudly about their skills with meat. They claim we Brits need an education in their ways of smoking and rubbing and glazing, and that our sausages and ribs need a bit of attention. And I have to agree with them! (not the sausage bit though) I’ve been to the States and tasted their wares over and over, and each time we exclaim ‘Oh if only in Nottingham’. (O.K., so maybe we’ve caught up a little bit, of late – before I start getting hate mail!) And, aside from the fact it has the coolest backdrop of rough wood and metal-work, and you think the clientelle should all be wearing bandana’s à la Axel Rose, it smells like the best aromatic medley of cremations and candyfloss. But, we’re here to test the burger, right – does it live up to their hype? Hell yeah!

The Burger…

A yorkshire sourced chuck, brisket and beef rib mix, pit fired over charcoal. The meat has a depth of flavour – I’m guessing from the triple combo of meat cuts – which is unique to Red’s and tells you they really know their cows inside out. It’s succulent and juicy but still chargrilled, much to the pleasure of Mr MLLH (he’s the one who put’s our toaster on the number 5 setting!) Accompanied with the obligatory slice of lettuce and tomato but complimented by a tasty relish and the choice of 6 different flavoured sauces (Judas Ketchup my favourite). Plenty of options to dip your ‘skin-on’ fries in.

Red's True BBQ Burger, one of my favourite burgers in Nottingham

Inside Reds True BBQ Nottingham, industrial style decor with an open kitchen and a seperate bar


5. Southbank City, Nottingham

On a quest to make Tuesday’s the new weekend, we stumbled across this fifth masterpiece whilst playing a game of mid-week pool. Recently refurbished, this sports bar is actually not full of sweaty Football fans scratching their bellies, it’s popular and inviting with a nod to its home city in the surrounding decor. The beer’s great (Mr MLLH’s favourite in the whole city *big words* is Navigations American Saviour), the bar staff are super friendly and if sport’s your thing well you’re in the right place! But if burgers are your thing, then you’re also in the right place.

The Burger…

Expecting mediocrity (seeing as they don’t brag loudly about their culinary competence) we looked up from our first mouthfuls in unison with enthusiastic surprise – Southbank City, Nottingham, have nailed a great burger! It’s your standard wedge of minced beef, not the American thin style, more the chunky gastro-pub style, mixed with herbs and finely chopped onions. Cooked faultlessly to that perfect chargrilled finish but retaining its juices. It’s served with the usual accoutrements but’s it’s served well. There’s not a lot more to say other than that you’re not in some posh place here but you can expect surprising quality when it comes to their burger.Southbank City in Nottingham have gone back to basics with their burger but they've got it right and it has made it onto my list for the 5 best burgers here in Nottingham

So there you have it, not a comprehensive list – just my list. I’m sure there are a few more excellent burgers out there in the foodie city of Nottingham so please let me know if I’ve left off your favourite. Leave me a message below…

Looking for the best Sunday Roast in Nottingham? – Read Here


Searching for the best bars for a night out in Nottingham? Click here

Pin for later…The foodie city of Nottingham has a lot of fine restaurants, so I have compiled a list of my favourite 5 burgers - the best this city has to offer


2 Comments Add yours

  1. Jane Taylor says:

    Love the bit about the cows. Made me snort and nearly wake up Hubbie. I love burgers and love Nottingham but I haven’t been to any of these places! I need to get out more! Great photos and reviews! Starving now…

    1. Alex says:

      *hubby wakes up, finds you gnawing on his leg*

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *